Appraiser: Scott D. McPhaul owner of Authentic Appraisal LLC which is a Southeastern Wisconsin based real estate appraisal and automobile appraisal firm. Thirty (+) years of experience as a shade tree mechanic, collector car enthusiast and consultant, certified collision estimator and prior owner of an auto dealership with sales, service and body shop.


Authentic Appraisal LLC is devoted to the continuing support and service of the automotive marketplace. Our mission is to provide sound and accurate appraisals, with confidentiality to our clients, conducting ourselves in an appropriately professional manner with service and quality in mind which includes reasonable turn around times.

Member of the NADA Classic Car Advisory Board, Certified Graduate of Hooked on Classics Auto Appraisal Work Shop, Member of the Appraisal Institute, Past Member American Society of Appraisers, State of Wisconsin Licensed Appraiser and Certified Residential Appraiser   Subscriber of: Collector Car Price Guide/Old Cars Price Guide, Hemmings Motor News and NADA Classic and Collector Car Price Guide, Hagerty's Cars That Matter. An extensive automotive library including repair manuals, related books and cost data with a continuing collection of automotive magazines and literature that date back to the early 1900’s. Member/subscriber to multiple web based data and automobile auctions for up to date current value processing.

Phone 262-895-2354 or email: authentic.appraisalllc@gmail.com


Authentic Appraisal LLC is devoted to the continuing support and service of the automotive marketplace. Our mission is to provide sound and accurate appraisals, with confidentiality to our clients, conducting ourselves in an appropriately professional manner with service and quality in mind which includes reasonable turn around times.

Authentic Appraisal LLC

Collector Car Valuation Services

Appraisals for Collectible Vehicles - Classic/Antique/Exotic/Muscle Cars/Trucks and Customs